Abstract
Identifying mechanisms of kidney disease commonly involves comparing diseased samples with healthy reference tissues; however, the effects of variability in tissue procurement, storage, and donor characteristics remain underexplored. In this study, we systematically evaluated 3 reference tissue types — tumor nephrectomy (TN), pretransplant biopsies from living donors (LD), and percutaneous biopsies from healthy control volunteers (HC) — to determine their impact on differential gene expression across 3 diabetic kidney disease states. We observed distinct injury markers, cell state proportions, and gene signatures associated with procurement method, sex, and donor age. Adjustment for these confounding factors significantly influenced pathway analysis results. Specifically, correcting for age and sex eliminated significant enrichment of IFN-γ response when comparing the diabetes mellitus–resilient group and HC group. Processes related to biological aging were enriched in older reference tissues, potentially confounding disease-specific interpretations. Importantly, TNF signaling via NF-κB remained enriched in LD and TN samples relative to HC, even after accounting for confounders. These results underscore the critical importance of selecting appropriate control tissues and rigorously adjusting for confounding variables to reliably discern the molecular mechanisms underlying kidney diseases.
Authors
Rajasree Menon, Paul L. Kimmel, Edgar A. Otto, Lalita Subramanian, Christopher L. O’Connor, Bradley Godfrey, Cathy Smith, Fadhl Alakwaa, Celine C. Berthier, Minnie M. Sarwal, E. Steve Woodle, Laura Pyle, Ye Ji Choi, Patricia Ladd, John R. Sedor, Sylvia E. Rosas, Sushrut S. Waikar, Abhijit S. Naik, Ricardo Melo Ferreira, Michael T. Eadon, Markus Bitzer, Petter Bjornstad, Jeffrey B. Hodgin, Matthias Kretzler, for the Kidney Precision Medicine Project (KPMP)
Figure 2
Single-cell data.
